Personal Tax  problem with answer!
Options
AuntieT
Registered Posts: 96 Regular contributor ⭐
I've gone through one of the practice assessments and am not sure with an answer and wanted some feedback please.
Extract from question:
Julie is a higher rate tax payer. She omitted to include £1500 of savings income in her return for 2009/10.
Assuming the error was deliberate without concealment and Julie makes disclosure of the error without prompting, the minimum penalty for the error is.......
The answer according to the book is £120. I work it out as £150. My reasoning..
Minimum penalty 20%. Savings income = £1500, grossed up is £1875. Tax rate 40% Gives £750.
Penalty therefore 20% of £750 = £150.
It seems to me that they haven't "grossed up" the £1500 which I can't understand.
Any explanations?????
Thanks
Extract from question:
Julie is a higher rate tax payer. She omitted to include £1500 of savings income in her return for 2009/10.
Assuming the error was deliberate without concealment and Julie makes disclosure of the error without prompting, the minimum penalty for the error is.......
The answer according to the book is £120. I work it out as £150. My reasoning..
Minimum penalty 20%. Savings income = £1500, grossed up is £1875. Tax rate 40% Gives £750.
Penalty therefore 20% of £750 = £150.
It seems to me that they haven't "grossed up" the £1500 which I can't understand.
Any explanations?????
Thanks
0
Comments

They must be assuming that the £1500 is the gross amount.
£1500 x 40% = £600 x 20% = £120.
misleading though0 
Shouldnt you work out the penalty on the tax owing?
Grossed up it would be 1875 at 40% tax which is 750 however the bank has already stopped basic rate tax of 375 leaving tax owing of 375.
With a penatly at 20% this still doesnt give you the answer but penalty rates etc seem to have totaly gone out of my head tonight so im sorry i couldnt help you more0 
Thanks for responding. I've asked at work as well and they came up with the same two responses.
However they also said that as the question seemed un clear as long as I'd shown my workings.
Should be fine anyway!0
Categories
 All Categories
 1.2K Books to buy and sell
 2.3K General discussion
 18.9K For AAT students
 267 NEW! Qualifications 2022
 147 General Qualifications 2022 discussion
 9 AAT Level 2 Certificate in Accounting
 43 AAT Level 3 Diploma in Accounting
 65 AAT Level 4 Diploma in Professional Accounting
 8.9K For accounting professionals
 23 coronavirus (Covid19)
 274 VAT
 92 Software
 274 Tax
 138 Bookkeeping
 7.3K General accounting discussion
 194 AAT member discussion
 3.8K For everyone
 38 AAT news and announcements
 352 Feedback for AAT
 2.8K Chat and offtopic discussion
 590 Job postings
 17 Who can benefit from AAT?
 36 Where can AAT take me?
 44 Getting started with AAT
 26 Finding an AAT training provider
 48 Distance learning and other ways to study AAT
 25 Apprenticeships
 65 AAT membership