Help needed
Barry
Registered Posts: 101 Dedicated contributor 🦉
I wondered if anyone here can help resolve an argument. There is a client who has a portfolio of financial instruments and the guidelines say that between 30 and 50 % of the total portfolio value of the equity exposure should be limited. The clients portfolio manager balances the portfolio by buying and selling equity and debt instruments.
I know from my research that these instruments can be classed as available for sale but the audit manager has said they are not and should be classed as held for trading, but I don't see why. Can anyone shed and light on it?
I know from my research that these instruments can be classed as available for sale but the audit manager has said they are not and should be classed as held for trading, but I don't see why. Can anyone shed and light on it?
0
Comments
-
The explaination of these headings aren't too clear.. The wording "held for trading" determines it?!
From what you've said it doesn't sound like your client trades these, as its held for them by a portfolio manager that balances the investment.
The advantage of held for trading is that increases in fair value go through the P&L, whereas avialable for sale go through other comprehensive income.
This explains it a little more;
http://www2.accaglobal.com/members/publications/accounting_business/CPD/27804060 -
Forgot to mention; derivatives must be classed as held for trading.0
-
Whether your client is allowed to classify the instruments as available-for-sale depends on their past practice. If the portfolio manager is authorised to buy and sell the financial instruments in attempts to balance the portfolio BUT there is no intention to trade, and there is also no past practice of trading for short-term profit then they can be classified as available-for-sale. However, you need to be careful here because if the portfolio manager actively buys and sells instruments to generate short-term profits, you've got to classify them as held-for-trading which I think is where your audit manager is coming from - hence you need to check out your client's intention with this portfolio.
Kind regards
Steve0 -
Thanks both. Steve it seems you were right but my manager thought the classification as held for trading was for a different reason but after further investigation it was found your reasons were right. Thanks again.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.2K Books to buy and sell
- 2.3K General discussion
- 12.5K For AAT students
- 325 NEW! Qualifications 2022
- 160 General Qualifications 2022 discussion
- 11 AAT Level 2 Certificate in Accounting
- 56 AAT Level 3 Diploma in Accounting
- 95 AAT Level 4 Diploma in Professional Accounting
- 8.8K For accounting professionals
- 23 coronavirus (Covid-19)
- 273 VAT
- 92 Software
- 274 Tax
- 138 Bookkeeping
- 7.2K General accounting discussion
- 202 AAT member discussion
- 3.8K For everyone
- 38 AAT news and announcements
- 345 Feedback for AAT
- 2.8K Chat and off-topic discussion
- 582 Job postings
- 16 Who can benefit from AAT?
- 36 Where can AAT take me?
- 42 Getting started with AAT
- 26 Finding an AAT training provider
- 48 Distance learning and other ways to study AAT
- 25 Apprenticeships
- 66 AAT membership