Hiring new employee abroad, how would you handle the payroll?
Options
ZoeB94
Registered Posts: 4 New contributor 🐸
We plan to hire a new employee based outside of our country, and I’m trying to work out the most reliable way to do this. It would only be one person to begin with, so setting up a company in their country seems like quite a big step just to make one hire. A contractor setup was also interesting, although the role would really be a normal employee position, so I’m not really sure that’s the right route either.
Someone suggested using an employer of record. I’ve been looking at G-P as one possibility, where they would employ the person locally and deal with the payroll and employment side. This kind of setup looks reliable, but it's still not 100% clear to me where to go with this.
I’d be particularly interested in how you handled the payments and bookkeeping on the UK side, and whether there were any tax, payroll or reporting issues that weren’t obvious at the beginning.
Has anyone here dealt with a setup like that for a client or their own business?
Someone suggested using an employer of record. I’ve been looking at G-P as one possibility, where they would employ the person locally and deal with the payroll and employment side. This kind of setup looks reliable, but it's still not 100% clear to me where to go with this.
I’d be particularly interested in how you handled the payments and bookkeeping on the UK side, and whether there were any tax, payroll or reporting issues that weren’t obvious at the beginning.
Has anyone here dealt with a setup like that for a client or their own business?
0
Comments
-
Hi there,
I can offer a little perspective from the other side of the arrangement, having spent several years living in France and working as a self-employed contractor for a UK-based company.
While this arrangement worked for me, I would be rather cautious about recommending it where the position is, for all intents and purposes, that of an ordinary employee.
Here in France, for example, the authorities take a fairly dim view of disguised employment ("salariat déguisé"). Having only one client, even over an extended period, isn't necessarily a problem in itself, but if the contractor is effectively working under the direction and control of the company, with little genuine independence, there is a risk that the relationship could eventually be reclassified as employment.
The consequences for the company could be considerable, potentially including backdated social security contributions, employment-related liabilities and financial penalties. I believe similar principles apply in other countries, although the precise rules obviously vary.
One alternative worth investigating, besides an EOR, might be a specialist international payroll bureau, particularly one accustomed to dealing with companies employing just one or two people overseas.
For example, here in France, foreign companies can employ people directly without establishing a French subsidiary, provided they register with the relevant authorities and comply with French employment and social security obligations. There is even a dedicated government payroll service for such arrangements.
A payroll bureau could potentially handle much of the administrative burden without the expense of a full EOR arrangement, although the company would remain the legal employer and would need to ensure it complied with local employment law.
I can't offer much insight into the UK bookkeeping side of things, but given that you've already identified the role as essentially that of an employee, I would certainly explore these alternatives before going down the contractor route. It would be interesting to know which country you plan on hiring this individual in.
Hope that helps, and best of luck!
OscarMAAT0 -
Hi Zoe, Oscar covered the French side well, so here is the UK bookkeeping side, which is the part that usually catches people out.
With an employer of record, the person is not your UK employee. The EOR employs them locally and invoices you for the cost plus its fee. So do not put them through UK payroll, do not run RTI or PAYE for them, and do not add them to your UK pension auto-enrolment. In your UK books the monthly EOR invoice is a staff cost, not wages — I would give it its own nominal code, for example "Overseas staff costs — EOR", so it never gets mixed up with UK salaries or with contractor fees.
Work it through with real numbers before you agree anything. Say the local gross salary is €3,000 a month and the EOR charges a 10% fee, €300, so the invoice is €3,300 a month. At €1 = £0.85 that is £2,805 a month, or £33,660 a year. Book the invoice in pounds at the exchange rate on the invoice date, and keep the original euro invoice on file. If the rate moves to €1 = £0.87 by the time you pay, the same €3,300 costs £2,871, which is a £66 exchange loss (£2,871 - £2,805). Small each month, but it adds up, and it is exactly the kind of difference that looks like an error at year end if it is not explained.
Three things to check before the first hire. First, get the EOR's invoice breakdown in writing — salary, local social charges, and fee shown separately — so you can prove what the £2,805 actually was. Second, ask your adviser about the VAT treatment of the EOR's fees and about permanent establishment and corporation tax, because having someone working for you full-time in another country can create a taxable presence there even when the payroll is handled locally. Third, do not use a contractor arrangement for a role that is really employment, as Oscar warned: if it is reclassified later, the backdated social charges and penalties fall on the business, not just on the individual.
For one person, an EOR is usually the cleanest route. Just price the full €3,300, not only the €3,000 salary, and keep the contract, the EOR invoices and proof of local payroll taxes together in one file.0