Chattels 5/3 rule

hphil Registered Posts: 2
In my Osborne book. I am stuck on this question because an antique painting is sold for £300,000 that was originally bought for £60000. She had also spent £50,000 restoring the painting. As this is a Chattel sold at a gain for over £6000 why does the 5/3 rule not seem to apply in the answers?

It seems to not apply to all of the antique paintings in examples but does apply to any other antiques!


  • crispy
    crispy Trusted Regular SouthamptonRegistered Posts: 456
    I believe the 5/3 rule for chattels applies where the cost of acquisition is less than £ 6,000, in your example it was brought for £ 60,000.
  • PeterC
    PeterC Registered, Tutor Posts: 225
    Crispy is correct but you could apply the 5/3 rule, anyway. The actual gain is £190,000. The alternative is 5/3(300,000 - 6,000)=£490,000. The actual gain applies, as it is the lesser of the two.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Not registered?

Register to create your free account, talk to AAT members and start your own discussions.

Privacy Policy