Self assessment advice - underpaid tax estimate or actual??
Options
Hasher
Registered Posts: 1 New contributor 🐸
Hi. Hoping someone can help with this dilema.
Someone has, in April 2026, been sent a letter from HMRC requiring them to register for self assessment for the first time and provide a return for 24-25.
They are employed, with no other income except bank interest that exceeds 10k.
The self assessment form says this:
Underpaid tax included in PAYE coding (Page 2 of 2)
Enter the amount of estimated underpaid tax for 6 April 2024 to 5 April 2025 to be included in your PAYE tax code for 6 April 2025 to 5 April 2026 (from your PAYE Notice of Coding). Enter '0' if you do not have underpaid tax for the tax year:
If your 6 April 2024 to 5 April 2025 tax code was reduced during the year because of a change in circumstances, you may not have paid enough tax.
Look at your 6 April 2024 to 5 April 2025 PAYE Coding Notice (P2).
If it includes the message 'our estimate of the underpayment for the earlier part of the year is £xxxxx' then put this amount in the box above.
Question is, do they include that estimated value that was in the 25-26 tax coding, or, because we know the actual amount of tax due for 24-25 do we put that figure.
To illustrate.
Tax coding dated 12 March 25, says in note 4 'we previously told you you owe us £1249, we have included an adjustment to to reduce your tax free allowance by 6246 to collect 1249.
But having calculated the tax owed for 24-25 it comes to £945.
So not sure which figure to include, 1249 or 945.
Grateful for any advice.
Someone has, in April 2026, been sent a letter from HMRC requiring them to register for self assessment for the first time and provide a return for 24-25.
They are employed, with no other income except bank interest that exceeds 10k.
The self assessment form says this:
Underpaid tax included in PAYE coding (Page 2 of 2)
Enter the amount of estimated underpaid tax for 6 April 2024 to 5 April 2025 to be included in your PAYE tax code for 6 April 2025 to 5 April 2026 (from your PAYE Notice of Coding). Enter '0' if you do not have underpaid tax for the tax year:
If your 6 April 2024 to 5 April 2025 tax code was reduced during the year because of a change in circumstances, you may not have paid enough tax.
Look at your 6 April 2024 to 5 April 2025 PAYE Coding Notice (P2).
If it includes the message 'our estimate of the underpayment for the earlier part of the year is £xxxxx' then put this amount in the box above.
Question is, do they include that estimated value that was in the 25-26 tax coding, or, because we know the actual amount of tax due for 24-25 do we put that figure.
To illustrate.
Tax coding dated 12 March 25, says in note 4 'we previously told you you owe us £1249, we have included an adjustment to to reduce your tax free allowance by 6246 to collect 1249.
But having calculated the tax owed for 24-25 it comes to £945.
So not sure which figure to include, 1249 or 945.
Grateful for any advice.
0
Comments
-
Hi Hasher, use the £1,249 figure. That is the one the form asks for.
The box is not asking for the final tax bill for 2024-25. It is asking for the amount HMRC put into the 2025-26 PAYE code. The form words say "estimated underpaid tax ... to be included in your PAYE tax code for 6 April 2025 to 5 April 2026 (from your PAYE Notice of Coding)". Your coding notice dated 12 March 2025 says £1,249. So that is the figure to enter.
The £945 is the actual tax you worked out for 2024-25. That goes into the tax calculation on the return itself, in the normal way. The return will work out the tax due for the year, and then take account of the £1,249 that is already being collected through PAYE in 2025-26.
The gap is £1,249 less £945, which is £304. That is the amount HMRC is collecting through the code over and above the actual tax. It should be sorted when HMRC look at the return, and the code can be changed if it is still collecting too much. If you put £945 in the box instead, HMRC would think only £945 is being collected through PAYE, when £1,249 is in the code. That would give the wrong answer.
In short: enter £1,249 in that box, and let the return work out the £945 actual tax. Check the coding notice again after the return is filed, and ask HMRC to amend the 2025-26 code if it is still taking too much.0