PTX  loan question
topcat
Registered Posts: 452
Can anyone help with this question please?
On 1 November 11, Roweena had been given £15,000 loan on which she paid her employer 1% interest. On 1 July 2013 , Reweena repaid £3000 of the loan, but shemade no other repayment were made
How do you work out the taxable benefit in kind arising from the loan please?
On 1 November 11, Roweena had been given £15,000 loan on which she paid her employer 1% interest. On 1 July 2013 , Reweena repaid £3000 of the loan, but shemade no other repayment were made
How do you work out the taxable benefit in kind arising from the loan please?
0
Comments

You may use 2 methods (assuming 4% HMRC rate)
1) The average method uses the opening balance of the loan plus the ending balance of the loan divided by 2
i.e. at 5th April 2013 15,000
at 5th April 2014 12,000 (3,000 repaid)
average 13,500 @ 4% = 540
2) The strict method
15,000 x 3/12 (April to July) x 4% + 12,000 x 9/12 x 4% =150 + 360 = 510
The strict method is more beneficial.
Then deduct the interests paid by the employee
Contributions = (15,000 x 3/12 + 12,000 x 9/12) x 1% = 127.50
Benefit in kind arising from the loan :
510  127.50 = 382.50
Hope this helps
0 
MarieNoelle wrote: »You may use 2 methods (assuming 4% HMRC rate)
1) The average method uses the opening balance of the loan plus the ending balance of the loan divided by 2
i.e. at 5th April 2013 15,000
at 5th April 2014 12,000 (3,000 repaid)
average 13,500 @ 4% = 540
2) The strict method
15,000 x 3/12 (April to July) x 4% + 12,000 x 9/12 x 4% =150 + 360 = 510
The strict method is more beneficial.
Then deduct the interests paid by the employee
Contributions = (15,000 x 3/12 + 12,000 x 9/12) x 1% = 127.50
Benefit in kind arising from the loan :
510  127.50 = 382.50
Hope this helps
Thank you for your help it really is appreciated, especially on a Saturday night!
I did the average method as you had done but then wasnt sure where to go from the £540 as the AAT answer is £405?
so by power of deduction the interest paid by the employee has too be £135 but i have no idea where this is coming from, any ideas ?0 
MarieNoelle wrote: »You may use 2 methods (assuming 4% HMRC rate)
1) The average method uses the opening balance of the loan plus the ending balance of the loan divided by 2
i.e. at 5th April 2013 15,000
at 5th April 2014 12,000 (3,000 repaid)
average 13,500 @ 4% = 540
You need to multiply 13,500 (the average balance) and mulitply by 3% (because HMRC rate is 4% and she paid 1% of it so the benefited from the remaining 3%)
13500 * 3% = 405
Hope this helps0 
And to answer to your last post 1% * 13500 (the average balance) = 135 as you deducted0

liveprincess wrote: »And to answer to your last post 1% * 13500 (the average balance) = 135 as you deducted
thank you very much ! all of the puzzle has finally fit together now :001_smile:0
Categories
 All Categories
 1.2K Books to buy and sell
 2.3K General discussion
 18.9K For AAT students
 247 NEW! Qualifications 2022
 137 General Qualifications 2022 discussion
 8 AAT Level 2 Certificate in Accounting
 33 AAT Level 3 Diploma in Accounting
 59 AAT Level 4 Diploma in Professional Accounting
 8.9K For accounting professionals
 23 coronavirus (Covid19)
 274 VAT
 92 Software
 274 Tax
 136 Bookkeeping
 7.3K General accounting discussion
 193 AAT member discussion (AATQB, MAAT, FMAAT and AAT Licensed Accountants and Bookkeepers)
 3.8K For everyone
 39 AAT news and announcements
 352 Feedback for AAT
 2.8K Chat and offtopic discussion
 589 Job postings
 17 Who can benefit from AAT?
 36 Where can AAT take me?
 44 Getting started with AAT
 26 Finding an AAT training provider
 48 Distance learning and other ways to study AAT
 25 Apprenticeships
 65 AAT membership