Phew! ECR done
Comments
-
I did that way.
0.8 less 0.3 gave me 0.5 as a contribution.
So divided fixad cost by 0.5 gave me 625000 revenue.
Make profit: (fixed cost + expecting profit)/contribution = 1025000
I did all losses nearly like many of You but I didnt call this abnormal and normal and I calculated cost per tonne as at: 73960/400=184,9 but then i calculated by 388 which gave me 190, but in account I put on denit 400 and on credit side 28 then 360 and then 12 and (!!!!) called as P+L. My fault:thumbdown:
Anyway looking forward to being surprised by FRA :laugh:I didn't get 2 years 1 month - I thought it was (95ish) negative with the cash flow in year 3 of 135 - therefore about .7 of a year? (95/135) about 2 years 8 months. (39K NPV ish) but with a sub note about the £50000 not coming in until the end of year 3... I think there must have been two papers!! lol...
I got the exact same as you!!!0 -
Oh no... did it say all losses? You probably are right then! Oops!!
The £20 per tonne scrap money only goes in the process account for the normal loss. Doesn't matter for the question whether abnormal loss can be sold for scrap or not cos only had to do the process account. Abnormal losses are charged at output rate in the process account whether they can be sold for scrap or not.0 -
Ok great, thanks.. were we meant to put direct labour and overheads on the debit side on seperate lines to the materials input?0
-
Oh no... did it say all losses? You probably are right then! Oops!!Ok great, thanks.. were we meant to put direct labour and overheads on the debit side on seperate lines to the materials input?
Yes - that's how it's normally done on the debit (input) side.
Only the credit side you keep them together : 'output', 'loss', 'WIP' (there wasn't any WIP but if there was it would be one line)0 -
came out the exam head in the shed but after reading what people have written on here i feel a bit more confident now:thumbup1: but not looking forward to FRA on wednesday the past papers for ECR were totally different to exam yesterday - good luck to all for wednesday:thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:0
-
Yes - that's how it's normally done on the debit (input) side.
Only the credit side you keep them together : 'output', 'loss', 'WIP' (there wasn't any WIP but if there was it would be one line)
Great.. thanks.. I struggled with that question.. but got there in the end!
I did FRA in Dec.. and the ECR yesterday was the hardest exam I have done!!
Good luck to all of u doing FRA tomorrow0 -
I agree with you esme. FRA was a walk in the park compared to yesterdays ECR.
Resit in December for me Im sure.0 -
i got 625000 for breakeven and 1025000 for target profit as well.Everyone else seems to have different answers to me and you breakeven and MOS.
625000 is expressed in number of cans, not in sales revenue, multiply by selling price of £0.8 gives £500,000 break-even in sales revenue, as they asked. same for profit target.0 -
Ggrrrr!
I feel a little better after reading what everyone else has said, I to was feeling ok about this exam, despite revising for FRA all weekend by accident! However, once I opened the paper, I couldn't beleive how different it was. I also put LIFO for the first question, then changed my mind later on and went for AVCO. Could not believe how different this paper was to all the practice one's I have done. I think I actually laughed out loud when I came across some of the questions as I had not even looked at some of them! I'm not looking forward to tomorrows exam at all either now!
Resits December??!!
Good luck everyone!0 -
Well you know what - I actually was feeling OK about this exam but now - I GIVE UP!! I think considering we seem to have all made the same mistakes then the only conclusion is.... either we all didnt have the brains to read the question properly, or the paper was badly worded!! And I'm thinking the latter. Hopefully the pass mark will be reduced if most of us got the same answer.
I'm doubting what I put for the MOS% now aswell! I thought my 42% was OK but seemingly I used the wrong figure. Oh well, I think If I pass I pass - If not then.... I FAIL!!
It really was very naughty of the to put graphs in there, and not have a section on limiting facts (I rvised that lots). :001_rolleyes:0 -
Ecr 2009
I found the exam a bit hard. Used LIFO and forgot about abnormal loss in process costing. Does anyone know if we wll have the answers to the whole paper on here somewhere??0 -
oh confused one wrote: »got the MOS% wrong for sure as well as putting over instead of under absorbed - I also calculated the abnormal loss at same rate as normal loss - ah well resit here i come lol
I did the exact same with the valuing of the normal & abnormal loss. Did it all at £20 per ton. I've heard that the reason that AAT do not disclose the pass rate before or after the exam is because the pass rate is determined by how well the paper was answered in general. Anyone else heard anything like this?? :001_smile:0 -
a05boothrj wrote: »I did the exact same with the valuing of the normal & abnormal loss. Did it all at £20 per ton. I've heard that the reason that AAT do not disclose the pass rate before or after the exam is because the pass rate is determined by how well the paper was answered in general. Anyone else heard anything like this?? :001_smile:
Yes that is what they do. So hopefully, if we all seemed to struggle on the same questions, there may be some light at the end of the tunnel :thumbup1:0 -
Kalpana Pankhania wrote: »I found the exam a bit hard. Used LIFO and forgot about abnormal loss in process costing. Does anyone know if we wll have the answers to the whole paper on here somewhere??
The paper is released on 24th June but answers are a day or two before the results.
I had the worst nights sleep not sure ablout anyone else kept waking up thinking dam i missed that :thumbdown:0 -
625000 is expressed in number of cans, not in sales revenue, multiply by selling price of £0.8 gives £500,000 break-even in sales revenue, as they asked. same for profit target.
yeh same as what i did after being confused about it for ages!! but got there in the end. i wanted a memo at end sooo bad -.- but look out there WILL be one in FRA to test memo writing me thinks.
0 -
Ecr Exam
Hi
What did everyone put for the Stock Ordering Policy - task after the stock card? Think I've made a boo with this one!
Sue0 -
Hi
What did everyone put for the Stock Ordering Policy - task after the stock card? Think I've made a boo with this one!
Sue
Hi Sue, do you mean the one where you were asked if the policy was complied with? If so i think i put that there was two non compliances, the first being that they ordered when stock levels were above the re-order level and the second being that they ordered in less than the re-order quantity.0 -
Stock Policy
Hi Jo
Can't remember the exact wording but something to do with which stock method would the company use if they are ordering in batches of 70,000, assumed it must be either EOQ or level method of re-ordering but think i went for the wrong one and was wondering what everyone else put!
Sue0 -
did the questions about break even point,target profit and MOS ask for the answer in units or monetry value?As i put:
breakeven point 312500/0.5=625000 UNITS
Also will i still get some marks for this?0 -
Sue, i put EOQ for that question.
Chris, from memory I think it asked for sales revenue not units.0 -
Didn't they allow the stock levels to drift below the minimum amount?Hi Sue, do you mean the one where you were asked if the policy was complied with? If so i think i put that there was two non compliances, the first being that they ordered when stock levels were above the re-order level and the second being that they ordered in less than the re-order quantity.
I seem to recall 3rd June took them below the minimum, until the recipts on 4the June.
I've no doubt I could be wrong...0 -
I did the breakeven in units too, by mistake.did the questions about break even point,target profit and MOS ask for the answer in units or monetry value?As i put:
breakeven point 312500/0.5=625000 UNITS
I'm hoping there'll be some form of marks for showing the workings for it, just a deduction of marks for not converting to revenue.0 -
i did the units then at last min saw the revenue bit so just multiplied it by sales price0
-
-
-
I put that they did let the stocks drop below the level in the policy on the 3rd June. The new stock didn't come in until the 4th June. The policy stated that when stock was ordered it would arrive on the same day.0
-
B/e, mos, mos%
:thumbup:Andypandy
Member Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Nottingham
Posts: 15
Did anyone else get £500,000 for break-even , with a MOS of £375000 - 42. something%?
_________________________________________________________________
I put all the same!! WAHOOOOOO0 -
-
Hi Jo
Can't remember the exact wording but something to do with which stock method would the company use if they are ordering in batches of 70,000, assumed it must be either EOQ or level method of re-ordering but think i went for the wrong one and was wondering what everyone else put!
Sue
I remember the question stated that there was no lag time and the items were assumed delivered as soon as they were ordered, so it would've been the EOQ they were asking for rather than reorder level.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.2K Books to buy and sell
- 2.3K General discussion
- 12.5K For AAT students
- 322 NEW! Qualifications 2022
- 159 General Qualifications 2022 discussion
- 11 AAT Level 2 Certificate in Accounting
- 56 AAT Level 3 Diploma in Accounting
- 93 AAT Level 4 Diploma in Professional Accounting
- 8.8K For accounting professionals
- 23 coronavirus (Covid-19)
- 273 VAT
- 92 Software
- 274 Tax
- 138 Bookkeeping
- 7.2K General accounting discussion
- 201 AAT member discussion
- 3.8K For everyone
- 38 AAT news and announcements
- 345 Feedback for AAT
- 2.8K Chat and off-topic discussion
- 582 Job postings
- 16 Who can benefit from AAT?
- 36 Where can AAT take me?
- 42 Getting started with AAT
- 26 Finding an AAT training provider
- 48 Distance learning and other ways to study AAT
- 25 Apprenticeships
- 66 AAT membership